32 Non-Candy Halloween Treats Kids Actually Want

Updated September 7, 2023

From spooky trinkets and toys to allergy-friendly snacks, parents are sharing the non-candy Halloween treats that have been the biggest hit with their trick-or-treaters over the years.

Depending on what fun Halloween activities you have planned, these also make great school favors, party game prizes or Halloween gifts for kids.

Have you given out any Halloween candy alternatives that your trick-or-treaters loved? Share your reviews below!

23 Recommendations

Sort/Filter :

amzn.to

Wikki Stix Trick or Treat Packs

Beth Wood said: Give out a fun Halloween craft! My kids love playing with these packs of colorful, non-toxic wax and yarn sticks. You can twist, bend, mold and stick them together with just a fingertip of pressure to create 3-d shapes and images. These sticks are reusable. The trick or treat packs come with halloween designed themed cards that encourage shape building such as cats, ghosts, and pumpkins.

amzn.to

Vampire Teeth

Kristy Pepping said: These fake teeth are a hit as non candy Halloween treats and won't lead to any sugar high!

amzn.to

Mini Noise Putty

Beth Wood said: Mini bottles of noise putty in different colors are fun non candy Halloween treats. Putty and slime are all the rage with kids right now!

amzn.to

Slap Bracelets

Vanessa M. said: Slap bracelets never go out of style! Trick or treaters will be happy to get these in their pumpkins on Halloween night.

amzn.to

Boo Buddies Giant Eraser Pencils

Beth Wood said: These assorted Halloween themed pencils with giant erasers are great non candy Halloween treats!

amzn.to

Mini Halloween Magic Springs

Jennie Utsinger said: Magic springs are always the first toy my kids reach for in toy baskets at fairs or doctor's offices. They can't get enough of these little slinky-like toys. They often twist them into oblivion fairly quickly, so would be thrilled to find a new one while trick-or-treating!

amzn.to

Vampire Lip Whistles

Beth Wood said: This is my kid's favorite find this year! These vampire lip whistles are lots of fun for a wide range of ages. They love the built-in siren whistle that is easy to blow.

amzn.to

Brain Shaped Erasers

Kelly R. said: I love that these brain erasers fit right in at Halloween, but won't become obsolete when the calendar hits November. A subtle reminder to use your noodle!