44 Easter Egg Fillers That Aren't Junk (Parents Vote!)

We're collecting a big list of parent-submitted ideas for Easter egg fillers that aren't junk!

Egg hunts are high on the list of our favorite Easter activities, but they're notorious for cheap candy and plastic trinkets that go straight to the landfill. Let's share ideas for toys and gifts that are fun for repeat play, far beyond Easter morning.

Add your favorite Easter egg stuffers below, and check out our list of Easter basket gifts for more fun ideas!

As an Amazon Associate, Upparent may earn commission from qualifying purchases from Amazon.com.

31 Recommendations

Sort/Filter :

amzn.to

LED Light Up Shoelaces

Beth Wood said: Super fun light up shoelaces are the perfect Easter egg stuffers! These nylon shoelaces with lights work with any shoes - including running shoes, boots and skates.

wondermomwannabe.com

Printable Kid Coupons

Gina I. said: Kid coupons are a great way to cut down on all the easter egg toys and still give your kids a fun egg hunt experience. Best of all, you can print these for free! From Wondermom Wannabe

amzn.to

Easter Egg Stampers

Brigitte Nohra Miller said: These egg shaped stampers are a hit in our house! The patterns are a nice size, colorful and make a clear drawing. My little girl found them easy to grab.

amzn.to

LEGO Minifigures

Kelly R. said: LEGO minifigures are epic Easter egg fillers! My kids go nuts for the mystery packs, and I LOVE that they now come in sets of 6 with no duplicates.

amzn.to

EOS Lip Balm

These egg-shaped lip balms are a great idea if you're looking for Easter egg fillers for tweens or teens!

amzn.to

Miniature Dinosaur Figures

Gina I. said: With these adorable mini dinosaurs, your child will have a whole dinoland play set when the egg hunt is over!

amzn.to

Glow-In-The-Dark Mini Stars

Beth Wood said: Perfect Easter egg fillers for your space fanatic! Adhesive is included to create your own night sky on your child's bedroom ceiling.

amzn.to

Animal Erasers

Erin P. said: Fun school supplies make the perfect Easter egg fillers that aren't junk, and kids love these adorable erasers.

amzn.to

LEGO Easter Set

Kelly R. said: LEGO Easter egg fillers are a hit with pretty much any kid. You can divide a full set among the Easter eggs and tuck the building instructions into the Easter basket! LEGO has a variety of Easter-themed sets that would be perfect for this, but pick a set in whatever theme appeals to your kid.

amzn.to

Play-Doh

Kelly R. said: Play-Doh is great for some quiet creative play on an exciting day, and kids will love having a nice variety of colors for their creations.

amzn.to

ALEX Farm Finger Crayons

Kelly R. said: These chunky and durable crayons are perfect for little hands, and each one has a unique farm animal face. They also double as finger puppets and stacking toys! Great Easter egg fillers for larger eggs.

etsy.com

Easter Treasure Hunt Printables

Kelly R. said: Last year, my kids got a kick out of an Easter egg treasure hunt. Each egg contains a clue that leads to the location of the next egg, and ultimately the hidden Easter basket gifts! All you need is some imagination and paper to pull this off, or use a pre-made list from Etsy.

amzn.to

Suncoat Girl Mini Nail Polish

Gina I. said: Non toxic nail polish for kids that is all natural and odorless! These mini nail polishes from Suncoat Girl make the perfect Easter egg fillers for little princesses who love to be pampered!

amzn.to

Mini Slow Rising Squishies

Beth Wood said: Slow rising foam squishes are popular among the 9-12 year old group and make fun gifts for tweens. These make great fidgets for the classroom as well. They are sweet smelling and squishy.

amzn.to

Rabbit Puzzle

Kelly R. said: Divide the pieces of a rabbit puzzle among a variety of Easter eggs, and kids can spend a little quiet time assembling the puzzle after the frenzy of the hunt is over! Choose a puzzle that's right for your kids' ages, and with pieces that will easily fit inside your eggs.